How to choose a content agency in Kazakhstan: 10 questions for the first meeting
Translated from Russian.
In short
At the first meeting, look at three things: which case studies the agency is proud of, whether it can explain its approach clearly, and whether it has experience in your category. You almost can't verify the numbers in someone else's case studies, but you can judge whether they're plausible and talk to the agency's client. I'd choose a local agency: that doesn't mean inexperienced, and it's more flexible.
10 questions to ask an agency at the first meeting
- Show me two or three case studies you're genuinely proud of. Why these ones? Everyone has plenty of cases, and there's no point looking at all of them. What matters is what the agency itself considers strong work: how complex it is and what approach is behind it.
- Have you worked in our category? What was hardest there? The more complex the category, the more experience in it matters.
- What business problem do you see behind our request? A good agency asks questions first and only then proposes a solution.
- How will you know the content is working? Which metrics will you propose? “We'll publish posts” is a reason to be wary.
- Who exactly will work on the project? Meet the people, not just the person selling.
- How do approvals and deadlines work? This quickly shows whether the agency has a process.
- What's included in the price, and what's paid separately? Production, promotion, revisions, media budget.
- What will you do in the first month, and when should we expect first results?
- Can we talk to one of your clients? It's the most reliable way to check a case study.
- What do you do if the results aren't coming? The agency should have an answer, not a promise that it never happens.
Red flags at the first meeting
For me, the biggest red flag is when someone can't clearly explain what they're offering. It happens more often than you'd think.
The ability to explain is underrated in general. It's the same with AI: if you can't explain a task to a colleague or a team member, you'll always get poor results from AI too. An agency that can't explain its approach clearly to you is unlikely to explain it clearly to its own team.
What a good proposal looks like
I write proposals more often than I receive them, but a bad one is obvious right away: it just states a price, or a list of operational tasks with a price.
That goes against the basics of sales. People buy when the pain of losing the money is smaller than the value they get. So a good proposal always answers the question “I'll pay this amount and get what?”.
I like the presentation format, where:
- there's a sequence: each slide follows logically from the previous one;
- there's no chaos and no attempt to bury you in approaches and jargon;
- everything is clear and easy to follow.
How to check the numbers in an agency's case studies
The honest answer is that you almost can't. For example, includes data on sales growth and brand share. If someone asks us to prove it, the answer is: we can't. That's the client's data, and we won't share it.
What you can do:
- judge whether it's plausible. If an agency claims it raised sales by a thousand percent, that's a reason to ask follow-up questions;
- talk to the client from the case study and ask what working with the agency was like.
Does the agency need experience in your category
Yes, and the more complex the category, the more it matters. We work with pharmaceutical companies all the time, and for them experience in pharma is almost the main selection criterion, apart from price. Telecom looks for an agency with telecom experience, real estate for one with real estate experience.
The reason is simple: complex categories have a lot of restrictions and specifics, and an agency without experience will be learning on your budget.
A big agency or a local one
A big agency has lots of people and established approaches. But it probably won't adapt to you: it has a hundred more clients just like you. A local agency has fewer people, and there's a risk it lacks experience.
I'm still for a local agency. Local doesn't mean inexperienced: TELLER is in many ways a local agency too, and we have plenty of and experience. A local agency is more flexible, and you can grow together and shape how it works around you.
How we run a first meeting
We ask about business goals, the market context and what competitors are doing. These are standard questions, and they're all in our brief.
What's more interesting is that clients rarely come to us with a ready-made solution like “we need a Telegram channel”. Much more often they come with a business problem and say: here are our competitors, we think this will work. Our job is to test that assumption before launching anything.
A story from practice
Once a client came to us for branding after working with a large, much-awarded Kazakh agency. They showed us what had been made for them, and honestly, it horrified our whole team. Before any contract, we showed them what it could look like. The client admired it for a long time, and then decided to stay with their previous agency.
Solai — as we say in Kazakh, that's just how it is.
Key points
- Ask to see two or three case studies the agency is proud of, and ask why those.
- The biggest red flag is an agency that can't clearly explain what it's offering.
- A good proposal shows value, not just a price.
- You can't verify the numbers in someone else's case studies, but you can judge their plausibility and talk to the client.
- In complex categories, the agency's experience in your niche is critical.
- Local doesn't mean inexperienced, and it's more flexible.
Choosing between several agencies? Message me on Telegram at @maximfetisov: in a consultation we'll go through your task and the contractors' proposals. The format and price are on the Services page.
→ My article on the TELLER blog (in Russian): How to choose a content agency: a guide for marketing and procurement













